Euro Psychoanalysis

Joe Wiesenthal does some interesting analysis on Greece:

In a post last night, economist Tyler Cowen asked: “Is the goal simply to irritate the Greeks so much that they leave the Eurozone on their own?”

Here’s what might be going on.

Sometimes in life you give someone a “shot” at something that maybe they don’t deserve. You hire them, despite the fact that their qualifications were marginal. Or something like that. Bottom line is, you think you’re doing them a favor, and you’re also putting your reputation on the line a little bit. But you expect that they’ll step up and really appreciate the opportunity they have. And you expect they’ll kill it.

And when they fail — which is likely, because they might not have deserved the opportunity — you’re furious at them, because you gave them this great opportunity and they totally blew it, and they made you look like an idiot at the same time. And you just hate them for it.

And that’s what’s going on now. Europe feels like it gave Greece a “shot” with Euro membership, and multiple bailouts. And now it looks to Greece, and sees people rioting, and the reforms not happening, and they’re furious like never before. Merkel, Schaeuble, and the rest just can’t fathom that Greece was given this great shot to be a rich, wealthy European nation and it’s totally blowing it.

Well, if that’s so, Europe never really understood the creature it was creating. For all the talk of the supposed various benefits of the Euro — lower inflation, integrated markets, and so forth— its one huge dilemma — that nations were now budgeting in a currency they didn’t control, and so could not just monetise debt — was always brushed aside. Of course, policymakers were aware of some of the problems, at least in an abstract sense.

As Romano Prodi put it in 2001:

I am sure the Euro will oblige us to introduce a new set of economic policy instruments. It is politically impossible to propose that now. But some day there will be a crisis and new instruments will be created.

I suppose what was never understood was that the problems might grow and multiply to the extent that they would pose a threat to global economic stability before such “policy instruments” were created.

I suppose the moral of the story is that it is dangerous to create systems with inherent problems, and assume that the solutions to these problems will naturally emerge later at a time of “crisis”.

And certainly, there does seem to be a sense of punishing Greece for their fiscal misdeeds (even though Germany themselves were the first nation to violate the Eurozone’s deficit rules).

From the BBC:

Some eurozone countries no longer want Greece in the bloc, Finance Minister Evangelos Venizelos has said.

He accused the states of “playing with fire”, as Greece scrambled to finalise an austerity plan demanded by the EU and IMF in return for a huge bailout.

Simply, if Europe wants to maintain the global status quo, the ECB needs to crank up the printing press, and fast, to pump huge liquidity into the system. Of course, this creates huge problems down the road, as exemplified by Japan.

If not, they had better be ready for huge changes to the global financial order. Personally, I believe that the global financial system is fundamentally broken, and that printing more money, kicking the can down the road and hoping for the best will just lead to a worse and bigger breakdown down the line. I favour liquidation. But policymakers can be very reactionary.

8 thoughts on “Euro Psychoanalysis

  1. Aziz,

    I believe you have a Jewish background.

    Read “Economic Analysis in Talmudic Literature, by Roman Ohrenstein and Bary Gordon”

    I think the natural cycles of economics/business have been disrupted by a misunderstanding of these cycles. We have fiddled with a machine that was above our capabilities.

  2. I suppose the moral of the story is that it is dangerous to create systems with inherent problems, and assume that the solutions to these problems will naturally emerge later at a time of “crisis”.

    And surely the corollary of that is that big government legislated solutions are themselves the root of the problem much of the time.

  3. I don’t buy the “unintended consequences” excuse. Either it’s deliberate or collateral damage. All the problems inherent in the common currency were predicted, but the proponents of it stated their intentions in advance. “But some day there will be a crisis and new instruments will be created.” does not indicate this being an accident, but foreseen and intended as an excuse to make changes that were previously electorally unpalatable. It’s not exactly a new idea, but a very old one used very effectively to pave the way for any change that will get rid of the devil you know.

    In the case of the Euro, the causes of the current problems are presented as the cure!

    Are civilian deaths in war an unintended consequence or simply collateral damage? If politicians and generals really cared about civilians, they wouldn’t go to war. Considering that the Eurocrats have broken their own rules, and no price has proved too big to pay for the “project” of European federation, the intentions are quite clear. The willingness to “replace” democratically elected leaders without authority to do so says it all, really. Is it too early to call it the fourth reich?

    • H.G. Wells called for the left to evolve into a “liberal fascism”. I don’t feel that it is completely inaccurate to apply that to the thing that we see in Europe. It is crucial that we point out, and continue to point out, the deficit in democracy and the lack of representation.

      Of course, I expect the final culmination of the EMU to be failure, and not greater consolidation.

  4. Because it’s a marketing piece, you should come up which has a headline that may instantly attract the attention of the reader. It should read like language stripped of most its minor connections.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s